Take My Money, HBO! Why HBO Would Rather Support Digital Piracy Than Take Your Money

Credit: TechnoBuffalo

With programming that reaches 29 million subscribers in the United States (Carter, 2012), Home Box Office (HBO) has hit pay dirt with its HBO GO website and mobile application. Launched in February 2010, HBO GO has revolutionized the way its customers receive its content. It’s apparent that HBO is in touch with what their viewers want. Not only does the pay-cable network continue to justify the additional cost to cable and satellite providers by delivering quality shows such as Game of Thrones and True Blood, but they’ve also expanded their reach through their streaming video (West, 2012). HBO GO can be accessed through various devices including the Apple iPad/iPhone, Android phones, and most recently, Kindle Fire. Additionally, with the hours of original HBO content, HBO GO also offers movies and other specials. With so much content available to paid subscribers through a multitude of ways, why has HBO resisted the recent cries by non-subscribers to access their application?


Credit: Screenshot, TakemymoneyHBO.com

One Web programmer has started a grass roots campaign in hopes that HBO will see differently. Jake Caputo has created a site called Take My Money, HBO!, which leverages Twitter (hashtag: #takemymoneyHBO) to convince the entertainment giant that they would benefit by allowing individual memberships to HBO GO. Within the first two hours of Caputo’s site going live, there were more than 12,000 visits (Lawler, 2012). Jake and others like him want to point HBO’s attention to the fact that a lack of access to HBO GO only helps to support digital piracy of their content. As advocates against digital piracy, does it not make sense for HBO and its owner, Time Warner, to step into the standalone streaming media service? Why continue to allow non-subscribers to obtain content for free?

As a paid subscriber to HBO through DirectTV, I have in the past shared my HBO GO log-on credentials with various family members, who could not afford to pay the extra for HBO. In doing this, I’ve always felt the Devil vs. the Angel dilemma that most individuals go through when ‘helping’ someone catch up on their favorite program. I wonder then as I do now – why prevent consumers, that aren’t as fortunate as others, to miss out on quality programming? HBO, nor Time Warner, have released an official comment on this, but their Twitter account (@HBO) has referred the media to a TechCrunch article that communicates the following:


The average person would pay $12 a month, or about $145 a year, for online-only access to HBO content. But is that something HBO would be interested in?

HBO currently has about 29 million subscribers, and reportedly receives around $7 or $8 per subscriber per month. So HBO could, theoretically, get more per subscriber than it’s currently making. But that doesn’t include the cost of infrastructure needed to support delivery of all those streams, including all the CDN delivery and other costs that would come with rolling out a broader online-only service.

More importantly, it wouldn’t include the cost of sales, marketing, and support — and this is where HBO would really get screwed. Going direct to online customers by pitching HBO GO over-the-top would mean losing the support of its cable, satellite, and IPTV distributors. And since the Comcasts and the Time Warner Cables of the world are the top marketing channel for premium networks like HBO, it would be nearly impossible for HBO to make up for the loss of the cable provider’s marketing team or promotions.

Think about it: Every time someone signs up for cable or satellite service, one of the inevitable perks is a free six- or 12-month subscription to HBO. And those free subscriptions are rarely, if ever, cancelled once the trial period ends. What would happen if HBO no longer had the pay TV industry’s marketing team propping it up all the time? The results would be disastrous, and there’s no way that HBO could make up in online volume the number of subscribers it would lose from cable. Which is why, even though some users would actually pay more for access to HBO GO without all the other cable channels, you won’t see it show up as a standalone service anytime soon.

In essence, HBO has pointed out that they are just one small member of a broader Time-Warner firmament and it has much more interest in sustaining that entire ecosystem than in picking up a few extra HBO Go subscribers (Yglesias, 2012). I doubt this is the best approach, especially when innovation is so desperately needed in an industry that’s in a battle against the Netflix and Hulu’s of the world.

Credit: appscout.pcmag.com

I would like to hear your thoughts on this. Considering the popularity of the Internet, do you think HBO is making a mistake by not welcoming the additional revenue from a standalone HBO GO service? Or should HBO continue to stand by their partnerships with the cable/satellite providers, even as their business model continues to be threatened by digital piracy, Hulu, etc.?


References:

Carter, B. (2012). With homeland, showtime makes gains on HBO. The New
York Times. Retrieved from
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/30/business/media/with-homeland-showtime-
makes-gains-on-hbo.html?_r=1&pagewanted=all

Lawler, R. (2012). How much would the average person pay for a standalone HBO go subscription? About $12 a month. Techcrunch.com. Retrieved from http://techcrunch.com/2012/06/05/hbo-go-without-hbo/

Pendlebury, T. (2012). New site calls for cable-free HBO Go option, but it’s an
uphill battle. CNET.com. Retrieved from http://news.cnet.com/8301-17938_105-
57448421-1/new-site-calls-for-cable-free-hbo-go-option-but-its-an-uphill-battle/

West, K. (2012). True blood season 5 bonus content available through HBO go
this sunday. Television Blend. Retrieved from
http://www.cinemablend.com/television/True-Blood-Season-5-Bonus-Content-
Available-Through-HBO-Go-Sunday-43332.html

Yglesias, M. (2012). HBO go and the innovator’s dilemma. Slate.com. Retrieved from http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2012/06/07/hbo_go_and_the_innovator_s_dilemma.html
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Take My Money, HBO! Why HBO Would Rather Support Digital Piracy Than Take Your Money